Observations on the commercial market, present-day (from an investor's perspective)

This is somewhat in response to the very informative and entertaining post on "how to calculate a cash yield", which might have also been titled "how to determine just how full of BS a sales broker is". Firstly, I by no means intent to offend any sellers or investment sales brokers with this post.
Given the challenges we are all currently facing, I have found that my interactions with sales brokers today compared with the peak period of 2004-2007 has changed dramatically. In the peak, brokers would be receiving so much interest in their marketed deals, they could have cared less if I wanted to schedule a property tour, submit an LOI, etc. Fundamentals went out the window. Brokers didn't need to fluff the proforma, the buyers did that for themselves. And the fat commission checks rolled in.
Today, different story. Most institutional investors are being advised by their lawyers and consultants to stay on the sidelines, the market is still headed downward.
In Buying Property - Asked by Eric G. - Jul 9, 2009
Report Abuse
Answer this Question

Answer(s)

Eric G.
Corporate Investor
Beverly Hills, CA

Why buy today when you will end up marking to market in 6 months for less? Even on the "distressed" assets, the markdowns do not accurately reflect what pricing needs to be for a transaction to exist.
In all of this, I have found many sales brokers seem, for lack of a better word, clueless as to what is really happening in the marketplace. I get calls all the time to give a broker my opinion of value on a specific deal. Free appraisals, I call them. In some cases, I almost feel badly for these guys, they want so desperately for someone, anyone, to submit an offer. Perhaps they blew their commissions and never saved for a rainy day.....pity for them.
What still amazes me, if you search via Loopnet for any property type, you will see cap rates being "advertised" at sub-6's, which in my view is totally ludicrous! Especially in the office and retail asset classes, who in their right mind would ever pay down to those caps given the risk....it's plastered on the front page of the WSJ everyday how some retailers is filing BK, or some office tenant downsizing.
When I first started out in the business 10 years ago, I worked for a high net worth investor/developer, the type of guy who obsessed over every detail of a deal, I would spend weeks drafting and editing books we sent to lenders for debt requests, or equity request books, or internal offering memorandums. So I was trained very early on to understand who you are marketing your asset to, what type of returns are required by that audience, etc. Never, in a billion years, would I have sent out a debt/equity request book showing cash yields in the 2-4% range, you might as well tell the bank/investor "Go buy T-Bills!". Just common sense.
Yet, I read offering memo's every week where it talks about how great an asset is, then you flip to the financial section and it shows a 5% going in cap, crazy rent growth assumptions, vacancy of 5% when the market is actually 10 or 15%, and the BS goes on and on.
And these are not small brokerage groups, this goes from CBRE all the way down the line. Regarding principal reduction being added back into a cash yield, the brokerage group based in Encino with the initials M&M (wink wink) are the kings of using that methodology to fluff their returns, I spent about 45 minutes on the phone once with one of their brokers explaining why that was a BS move to include that in their numbers....I still don't think he understood.

Jul 9, 2009
Report Abuse
Srini P.
Owner/Investor
San Jose, CA

Hi Eric,
Nice observation.
I am a new to commercial investing and looking to get started.
Any advise for a newbee like me?

Jul 13, 2009
Report Abuse

Welcome to Answers

LoopNet Answers is where the commercial real estate community shares what they know to help each other out. And it's all for free.

Ask a question to get advice from brokers, investors, professionals and local experts.

Answer questions to raise your visibility as a trusted advisor and build new relationships.

Ask a Question

Post Question